Firm Strategy and Positioning

Backkr vs Hiring a Marketing Agency: The Retainer Alternative

Compare Backkr with an agency retainer: what each provides, current pricing, the work you still own and when a hybrid approach makes sense.

By Kate Radcliffe-Reid, Founder at Backkr · Updated 16 November 2026

Should a professional-service firm use Backkr or hire a marketing agency?

Choosing Backkr instead of a marketing agency retainer in New Zealand depends on whether your firm needs relationship opportunities or outsourced execution. Backkr supports discovery and preparation, while an agency engagement can provide agreed delivery support; either approach needs clear ownership and realistic capacity.

Choosing Backkr instead of a marketing agency retainer in New Zealand depends on whether your firm needs relationship opportunities or outsourced execution. Backkr supports discovery and preparation, while an agency engagement can provide agreed delivery support; either approach needs clear ownership and realistic capacity.

For a professional-service firm, the decision is less about which option produces the biggest report and more about who will build relationships, do the work and keep it moving.

What an agency actually gives you

A marketing agency engagement can provide execution capacity, strategic input, specialist skills and accountability when those responsibilities are included in the agreed scope. Assess the actual proposal rather than assuming every retainer provides the same support. Clear deliverables and reporting make it easier to judge whether outside help fits the firm.

  • Execution capacity – people who will do the work when you cannot.
  • Senior strategic thinking, if that is included in the engagement.
  • Specialist skills you would not hire full time.
  • Accountability, when responsibilities and reporting are clear.

A law firm planning a website rebuild may need designers, developers and an experienced project lead. A consultancy running complex paid campaigns may need ongoing specialist management. Software alone does not provide those people.

Ask which individuals will do the work, what experience they bring and what the agreed scope excludes. An agency's value depends on the actual arrangement, not the label.

Marketing agency retainer vs. a relationship-led system highlights responsibilities to clarify before choosing an approach.

AreaAgency retainerBackkr and Handshake
Who builds the relationshipsAgree responsibilities within the engagementFirm leads participation and personal follow-up
What you pay forAgreed services and delivery scopeBackkr subscription; Handshake is a free companion
Control of messagingAgree briefs and approvalsFirm prepares and approves its messages
Knowledge kept in the firmAgree documentation and handoverFirm retains conversation context and relationship knowledge
Best suited toFirms needing agreed external executionFirms able to own relationship-building activity

What an agency costs you

An agency retainer should be assessed by the work and responsibilities included in the proposal, not the headline fee alone. Strategy, production, account management and reporting may sit within the scope, while other work may be separate. Clarify inclusions and internal responsibilities before deciding whether the engagement is suitable.

Compare written scopes rather than assuming every retainer buys the same thing. Also consider your own time: briefing, compliance review, approvals and access management remain important even when delivery is outsourced.

Distance from your data, queues for changes and knowledge leaving at the end are risks to manage, not inevitable features of agency work. Agree account ownership, access, handover materials and cancellation terms before signing.

What Backkr gives you

Backkr helps professional-service experts describe their ideal client and discover relevant events, online communities, complementary referral partners and content opportunities, including podcasts. The firm chooses where to participate and handles outreach and follow-up. Backkr supports relationship discovery and preparation rather than supplying an outsourced team to execute all marketing activity.

It also builds customer personas, a marketing strategy, a content planner, a web/SEO and AI-search audit, website-lead improvements and a brand book. You can optionally connect GA4 or use illustrative sample data without website or GA4 access.

Those capabilities support decisions and preparation. They do not mean an agency team is writing, designing, buying media or managing your relationships on your behalf.

What Backkr costs you

Backkr requires a software subscription and time from the firm to assess opportunities, contribute expertise and follow up personally. Review the current pricing alongside the internal work required, rather than comparing subscriptions with agency fees alone. A relationship-led system still needs an owner and a realistic delivery routine.

The site auto-localises pricing to the visitor's currency. Annual saves two months. Check pricing when comparing your options.

The other cost is your time, or a collaborator's time, to do the work. Someone still needs to select opportunities, make contact, prepare useful contributions and follow up personally. Introductions and client wins are not guaranteed.

The real decision

Choosing between an agency retainer and a relationship-led system depends on who will make decisions and who will do the work. Identify the expertise and execution capacity already available inside the firm. Then decide whether the missing support is opportunity discovery, specialist delivery, coordination or a combination of those needs.

Do you have someone who will do the work? An owner with protected time, an in-house marketer or a freelancer with an agreed scope may all qualify. If the answer is genuinely no, software will not solve the capacity problem.

Do you know what work matters? A firm might be busy publishing generic posts while neglecting the professional communities where prospective clients seek recommendations. In that situation, clearer audience choices and a relationship-building plan may be more useful than buying more production.

Be honest about both answers. A plan without capacity stalls; capacity without direction can be expensive.

A practical hybrid

A hybrid marketing arrangement combines software-supported research and planning with people responsible for delivery, judgement and relationship-building. Assign each task to the firm, freelancer or agency best placed to handle it. Keep ownership clear so opportunity discovery leads to useful participation and personal follow-up rather than another unattended list.

  • A freelance marketer coordinates content and keeps follow-up tasks visible.
  • A specialist agency handles a defined rebrand or website project.
  • The owner or advisers attend relevant events and maintain professional relationships.

For example, a hypothetical accounting practice might use Backkr to explore referral partners, a freelance writer to develop useful articles and a web agency for technical changes. There is no assumed saving or guaranteed result; the point is to match each task with the right resource.

Our guide for freelance marketers reflects their role as partners in that work, not competitors to be replaced.

When to keep the agency

Keeping an agency makes sense when specialist execution remains valuable, internal capacity is limited and the agreed scope produces work the firm can assess. Review the arrangement when responsibilities are unclear, reporting does not support decisions or deliverables no longer match priorities. Judge the engagement against current needs rather than habit.

Before switching, agree a handover and preserve access to your accounts, assets and records. Agencies are not the enemy. Paying for an arrangement that does not fit the work is the problem.

Choose the support that leaves your firm able to take the next useful action.

See practical support for consultants and coaches when adapting the routine to your practice.

More in Firm Strategy and Positioning
Backkr cloud

Ready to try what we write about?